The best and quickest discussions of a scientific paper now sometimes happen in science blogs rather than in the peer-reviewed literature. Whereas we have a number of scholarly databases that track citations between papers, we don’t have the same tools for science blogs. Following all science blogs manually has simply become impossible (unless your first name is Bora). This makes it difficult to find all blog posts about a particular paper - either for proper discussion of an article or for doing automated article-level metrics.
Aggregation can help solve this problem. ResearchBlogging aggregates blog posts about peer-reviewed research. ScienceSeeker aggregates all science blog posts (currently aggregating over 400 blogs) and was announced in February. Nature Blogs also aggregates science blogs, but doesn’t seem to be up-to-date.
Microformats are an alternative – but of course complimentary – strategy. Microformats are small snippets of HTML that represent commonly published things. A good example is Rel-License, a microformat indicating licensed content:
<a href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/" rel="license">cc by 2.0</a>
In February Google launched a new Recipe view feature based on the hRecipe microformat, demonstrating how microformats can help discovering content. There is currently no standard microformat for scholarly citations. The simplest format would again use the rel tag – together with the Citation Typing Ontology (CiTO):
<a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.1197258" rel="cito:discusses">this paper</a>
There are more than 20 CiTO tags for describing what we think about a particular paper or science blog post – many science bloggers would probably have used cito:critiques for the above paper. I suggest cito:discusses as the standard CiTO relationship for most papers and blog posts. You can add this tag manually, or use a tool such as the Link to Link WordPress plugin (I added cito:discusses to version 1.1.2).
How does the article of the future look like?
Last year Elsevier started the Article 2.0 Contest and asked for the best ideas on how research articles should be presented on the web. The winners were announced March 31:Inigo Surguy from 67 Bricks won first prize. ...
How do you read papers?
Working in science is as much about reading papers as it is about writing papers. There are usually two ways you can come across an interesting scientific paper:Active Searching. Literature search on a particular topicPassive Browsing. ...
Starting 2022 with a new feature: full-text search for the Front Matter blog
Fresh into 2022, the Front Matter blog today is launching an important new feature: full-text search of all blog posts. An example query would be for reference manager.As the Front Matter blog has a lot of posts about reference managers, ...